November 19, 2026
At 4402 Goldfinch Avenue in Olthof Homes' Midwood Terrace, a three-bedroom, two-bath Eden plan with 1,456 square feet and a two-car garage is listed as ready now for $329,951. That's $13,549 less than the median price of an existing Valparaiso home sold in October 2026, which was $343,500 according to the Northwest Indiana REALTORS Association's October 2026 Local Market Update.
A buyer who walked into a Valparaiso City Council meeting this June would have heard a much higher number. Bill Oeding of Paradise Community Homes, the nonprofit developer behind the planned Cumberland Corner subdivision, put the city's new-construction market rate at roughly $425,000 to $450,000, according to the council's minutes.
The gap between those two numbers comes down to the size of the house. In Valparaiso this fall, the lowest price for a brand-new home sits at or below the middle of the resale market. What brings a new build up to $425,000 or more is mostly size.
Here's what builders are advertising in and around Valparaiso this fall, listed from smallest to largest.
| Community | Builder | Home | Size | Price |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Midwood Terrace | Olthof Homes | Eden, ready now, 3 bed | 1,456 sq ft | $329,951 |
| Cherry Hill | Eagleview Homes | Manistee, proposed, 3 bed | 1,524 sq ft | $327,700 |
| Westwind | Olthof Homes | Ready now, 2 bed | 1,633 sq ft | $346,169 |
| Cherry Hill | Eagleview Homes | Driftwood, proposed, 3 bed | 1,693 sq ft | $359,700 |
| Midwood Terrace | Olthof Homes | Echo, winter 2026, 4 bed | 1,801 sq ft | $370,072 |
| Cherry Hill | Eagleview Homes | Whitewater, proposed, 4 bed | 1,973 sq ft | $367,700 |
| Cherry Hill | Eagleview Homes | Briarwood, proposed, 4 bed | 2,436 sq ft | $410,700 |
| Brigata Hills | Davis Homes | Quick move-in, 3 bed | 5,234 sq ft | $949,900 |
Olthof prices Midwood Terrace overall "in the $300s," with plans running from 1,456 to 2,386 square feet. Westwind, at 3860 Wild Grove Way, mixes single-family homes, villas and paired villas from the $300s into the mid-$500s. Brigata Hills on Brigata Drive is a different tier altogether. Davis Homes sells semi-custom ranch and two-story homes in its Traditions Collection there, on estate-style sites.
Six of the seven production homes in the table are priced between $327,700 and $370,072. The October resale median of $343,500 falls almost exactly in the middle of that band.
Divide each price by its square footage and the pattern is clear. The 1,456-square-foot Eden works out to about $227 a square foot. The Driftwood comes to about $212, the Whitewater about $186, and the 2,436-square-foot Briarwood about $169. Across these listings, larger plans cost more in total and less per square foot.
That arithmetic also explains the council figure. At the per-square-foot rates these builders are posting for their larger plans, $425,000 to $450,000 buys roughly 2,300 to 2,500 square feet of new house. The Briarwood at $410,700 for 2,436 square feet is already close to that. The $425,000 to $450,000 figure fits a typical four-bedroom new build. It doesn't fit the smallest plan on a builder's lot list.
So a buyer comparing a new build with an existing home at the same price is mostly deciding how much space they need. At about $330,000, Valparaiso's new-construction market has a three-bedroom home under 1,550 square feet. The resale market at that price will have a wider spread of sizes, ages and lots, and each of those homes has to be judged one at a time.
Midwood Terrace is worth a closer look because its prices were discussed in public before a single home went up. The land sits near County Roads 175 West and 500 North, and Olthof's plan for its portion called for 160 single-family lots plus attached townhomes and a fire station, Lakeshore Public Media reported in June 2025. At the June 9, 2025 council hearing, Olthof estimated its detached homes at $325,000 to $375,000 and described the townhomes as fee-simple, two-story homes sold individually, at an estimated $250,000 to $275,000, according to the city's minutes. Neighbors raised density, traffic and drainage at that hearing, and Olthof proposed dropping two townhome buildings and shrinking others. The council approved the annexation on June 23, 2025, by a 5–2 vote, as recorded in the city's ordinance archive.
Seventeen months later, the two homes Olthof has listed are $329,951 and $370,072, both inside the range the builder gave the council. The townhomes are marked "coming soon." The community plan includes a pond with an overlook, a walking path, a firepit, an outdoor kitchen and a pergola. If the townhomes come in near the 2025 estimate, Valparaiso's newest construction will have a price floor well below its resale median.
Eagleview's Cherry Hill listings each note that the homes are on Valparaiso City Utilities and that the construction loan isn't included in the price. These are proposed homes on specific lots, such as Lot 47 at 282 Apple Grove Lane and Lot 97 at 314 Holst Lane, so the house doesn't exist yet. A ready-now Olthof price and a proposed Eagleview price can look close in the table, but the buyer pays for them in different ways. This is general information and not legal, tax or financial advice, so confirm what a construction loan would mean for you with your lender before you compare the two side by side.
None of this means resale homes are losing ground on price. The Valparaiso resale median rose 11.9% from October 2025 to October 2026, from $307,000 to $343,500, and the year-to-date median through October was $342,000, up 12.9%. These figures include only previously owned single-family homes, half duplexes, townhouses, condos and manufactured homes. They leave out new construction, so the builder prices above are a separate market.
Speed is what changed. In October 2026, the median Valparaiso resale took 39 days to sell, up from 31 days in October 2025, and the year-to-date figure through October rose from 35 days to 43. Sellers still received 97.3% of their original list price in October 2026, compared with 95.3% a year earlier. The city had 90 homes for sale at the end of October, or 2.8 months of supply. October had 40 closed sales, and the report itself warns that a single month can swing on a sample that small.
Porter County as a whole looks similar. Its October 2026 resale median was $349,000, up 12.6% from a year earlier. Median days on market rose 17.9% to 33, and supply stood at 2.8 months, according to the association's Porter County report.
Taken together, this fall's buyer at around $340,000 has two real choices in Valparaiso. One is a new three-bedroom home with a set floor plan. The other is a resale home with whatever size and lot the right listing has, from sellers who are getting close to full price but waiting longer to get it. Our Valparaiso neighborhood guide covers the parts of town behind those listings.
Paradise Community Homes is planning a lower price point. Its Cumberland Corner plan covers 27 lots on a 5-acre site at the southeast corner of Bullseye Lake Road and Cumberland Drive, with home designs of about 800 to 1,200 square feet. The City Council rezoned the land from Business Park to Urban Residential in June 2026 by a 4–1 vote, with one member recused. According to the council minutes, Paradise Community Homes is aiming for prices that start around $250,000 and rise with size, and the Urschel Corporation agreed to donate the land. The nonprofit previously built and sold five homes on Kinsey Street.
These homes follow the same rule as the rest of the market. A $250,000 new build in Valparaiso is planned at under 1,200 square feet.
Is new construction in Valparaiso more expensive than resale? At the entry level this fall, no. Olthof's ready-now Eden at $329,951 and Eagleview's proposed Manistee at $327,700 are both listed below the October 2026 resale median of $343,500. New construction costs more once you move into plans of about 2,000 square feet and up.
Where does the $425,000 to $450,000 figure come from? Paradise Community Homes cited it at a June 2026 City Council meeting as the market rate for new construction. At the per-square-foot prices builders are posting for their larger plans, that budget lines up with a home of roughly 2,300 to 2,500 square feet.
Do the resale statistics include new builds? No. The Northwest Indiana REALTORS Association's monthly reports cover previously owned homes only and specifically leave out new construction.
If you're weighing a Midwood Terrace floor plan against a resale home at the same price, Meghan Maddox can walk through both with you, square foot by square foot, using her experience working with local builders. If you already own in Valparaiso and want to know where your home sits against these new-build prices, start with a free home valuation.
I am committed to guiding you every step of the way—whether you're buying a home, selling a property, or securing a mortgage. Whatever your needs, I've got you covered.